Currently the Florida Football Ring of Honor has five members: Wilber Marshall, Emmitt Smith, Steve Spurrier, Danny Wuerffel, Jack Youngblood, and Tim Tebow. In order to be considered for induction into the Ring of Honor, a former player or coach needs to have been absent from the University of Florida for five years, be in good standing, and meet one of the following criteria:
- Heisman winner (Spurrier, Wuerffel, Tebow)
- All-American in Pro Football Hall of Fame (Smith, Youngblood)
- All-American NFL career category leader (Smith)
- College-career category leader (Tebow)
- Coaches with a national championship (Spurrier)
- Coaches with three SEC championships (Spurrier)
- Players with two Consensus All-American honors also named national player of the year (Marshall, Tebow)
- Carlos Alvarez (CFB HOF 2011, UF HOF 2014, Consensus All-American 1969, UF career receiving yardage leader). He does not qualify currently because he is short a consensus All-American award and a national player of the year award; and he lacks a Pro Football Hall of Fame induction or NFL career category leader.
- Wes Chandler (CFB HOF 2015, UF HOF 1989, 2X First Team All-American). He does not qualify currently because he lacks a national player of the year award and a Pro Football Hall of Fame induction or NFL career category leader.
- Dale Van Sickel (CFB HOF 1975, First-team All-American 1928, UF HOF). He does not qualify currently because his First-team All-American award is not a Consensus award (I am not even sure if consensus awards were a thing back in 1928).
- Lomas Brown (CFB HOF 2020, Consensus All-American, UF HOF 1995)