It is too early to call the coaching search a fiasco. UF has multiple vetting teams, and we do not know which was the preferred option, just as we have never really known the entire set of options, except in 2002 when we leaked out that Stoops turned down the offer and we went with Zook--but he was a safe option anyway as a personal friend to Jeremy Foley and former assistant head coach under Spurrier. If all the options fail this time, Randy Shannon is our safe option, which is fine as long as we hire a top notch offensive coordinator, offensive line coach, QB coordinator, WR coordinator, and strength and conditioning coach.
From where I'm sitting (a pretty dark and dismal place, I admit), your arguments (until the last day or two very close to my own) now only seem to underline and further support my doomsday scenario above.
To me, it seems obvious that "fiasco" is the ONLY way to describe everything that has and/or hasn't been done in regards to our "Coaching change", from Day 1 on. The details (including the ones you yourself note comparing this to 2002 and the "Stoops to Zook"..., well, "FIASCO" applied pretty damn accurately THERE too!) only make my point from another angle: Extending that comparison, you are more or less implying that we MIGHT be ok IF history and fate repeat themselves, that IF WE'RE "LUCKY" we'll probably next get some (putting it nicely) "poor fit" as Coach--but it won't matter in the end because THAT will only lead eventually to the next Urban Meyer, a mercenary Outsider who will come in here with Carte Blanche and turn the whole thing around--recruit stars and playmakers all over the field (INCUDING at QB--and of course there are ALWAYS "Tim Tebows", lifelong Gator fans with great heart and spirit, not to mention freakish size and skills, at that position).
NOT that I'm against all that, of course--we'd all gladly take that trip again, eyes-wide-OPEN. No, only that I won't count on it. It isn't LIKELY to work out that way...
I'm sorry, E--, I know that ISN'T what you're saying, only that "the wheel is still turning and the little ball hasn't fallen into its slot yet"...But the fact remains, more than ever we are depending on luck, AND the work and wisdom of a handful of "men-in-the-shadows" who have botched EVERYTHING so far. Men who don't DESERVE our confidence OR trust.
Even "good fortune" requires one to "help oneself"--we need to at the very least put ourselves in POSITIONS that increase the odds, the positive possibilities and potential for good things to eventually come our way. We can think and discuss what we will, throw it out there and hope that, in addition to venting our frustration, we might in some small way help to shape the future. And modern physics supports that view, of a "quantum reality" that amounts to a shared vision created in our individually imagining that future, then sharing and acting it out in the world around us in various ways ("collapsing the waveform", in the language of current theory).
I'm not sure I am making it better by alerting y'all to where we're at and where I see us heading, or making it WORSE in sharing that view. But this AD and the guys around him are blindly blowing it for ALL of us! In the final analysis, they care only about themselves: The rest of us are NOTHING to them: They put their power, position and personal prestige ahead of all else.
None of us knows the future, even less the daily details. But we CAN recognize the motives, where we are and who will keep doing what they've BEEN doing so far--and in turn the likely consequences.
In the direction we are headed now, the BEST CASE future is a bad one for us. I see us gathering speed and momentum headlong towards disaster. Let's at least recognize it, begin to think in terms of what might be done to change that. Not just "Who to look for?" in the coaching search right now but anything that can be done to change how we go about it--and maybe how we affect who is currently in charge of that search. If we can't yet get that itself changed, what might put pressure on them to open things up, affect change in their thinking, maybe create an opening for fresh ideas, new people in there that might short circuit a hidebound system that will otherwise continue to fail us, will inevitably, inexorably sweep us on to the sad fate I see ahead.